dr_phil_physics (![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
dr_phil_physics) wrote2010-11-15 10:40 pm
dr_phil_physics) wrote2010-11-15 10:40 pm
Entry tags:
Did I Just Hear That Toyota Ad Right?
TV Ad For The Toyota Prius
Dad driving a kid around. Kid anxious to get "somewhere". Dad is explaining about Toyota's Synergy Drive System, essentially describing the dynamic braking system in which the kinetic energy of the moving car can be used to turn the electric motor into a generator and recharge the battery. So far that's all true -- it's Physics. And it's been used in other industries, oh such as railroads, for most of a century.
But then... the Dad in the commercial starts talking about maybe using the Synergy Drive is other areas. Like the roller coaster in the background. (Now we know where the kid wants to go.) And he comes up with the corker: "We could make the first self-sufficient amusement park." Or something like that. I've only seen the commercial once.
Excuse Me?
What in the world did they mean by "self-sufficient"? This sounds like they expect to get 100% of the kinetic energy of that roller coaster back from the Synergy Drive. Um, ever heard of the Second Law of Thermodynamics? Ever heard of a Perpetual Motion Machine? Or that the U.S. Patent Office refuses to issue a patent for such a device, on the grounds that it violates the Second Law of Thermodynamics?
Are you people crazy?
Okay, so it's just a damned commercial. No one thinks this Dad really is some engineer or scientist. And Lord knows that the people writing the ad copy know much about Physics. But this is or should well be embarrassing to Toyota's engineers. Without. Question.
Why Carp About Yet Another Ad?
Because this stuff matters. We have dumbed down our society, allowing them to graduate from middle school, high school, college and even graduate and professional schools, such that actors, directors, ad agencies, advertising departments of major international corporations -- don't know the Second Law of Thermodynamics.
Waste. Try as hard as you can to recover all the energy and reuse it, you can't. You have to waste some to recover some. At best. There is no alternative. It's Physics.
And Toyota is promoting their Synergy Drive as the engine of a perpetual motion machine? It's either out-and-out fraud or stupidity. Take your pick.
Assuming, of course, that I heard this commercial I've seen only once right. (grin)
Dr. Phil
Dad driving a kid around. Kid anxious to get "somewhere". Dad is explaining about Toyota's Synergy Drive System, essentially describing the dynamic braking system in which the kinetic energy of the moving car can be used to turn the electric motor into a generator and recharge the battery. So far that's all true -- it's Physics. And it's been used in other industries, oh such as railroads, for most of a century.
But then... the Dad in the commercial starts talking about maybe using the Synergy Drive is other areas. Like the roller coaster in the background. (Now we know where the kid wants to go.) And he comes up with the corker: "We could make the first self-sufficient amusement park." Or something like that. I've only seen the commercial once.
Excuse Me?
What in the world did they mean by "self-sufficient"? This sounds like they expect to get 100% of the kinetic energy of that roller coaster back from the Synergy Drive. Um, ever heard of the Second Law of Thermodynamics? Ever heard of a Perpetual Motion Machine? Or that the U.S. Patent Office refuses to issue a patent for such a device, on the grounds that it violates the Second Law of Thermodynamics?
Are you people crazy?
Okay, so it's just a damned commercial. No one thinks this Dad really is some engineer or scientist. And Lord knows that the people writing the ad copy know much about Physics. But this is or should well be embarrassing to Toyota's engineers. Without. Question.
Why Carp About Yet Another Ad?
Because this stuff matters. We have dumbed down our society, allowing them to graduate from middle school, high school, college and even graduate and professional schools, such that actors, directors, ad agencies, advertising departments of major international corporations -- don't know the Second Law of Thermodynamics.
Waste. Try as hard as you can to recover all the energy and reuse it, you can't. You have to waste some to recover some. At best. There is no alternative. It's Physics.
And Toyota is promoting their Synergy Drive as the engine of a perpetual motion machine? It's either out-and-out fraud or stupidity. Take your pick.
Assuming, of course, that I heard this commercial I've seen only once right. (grin)
Dr. Phil
no subject
no subject
Dr. Phil
no subject
Okay, yeah, I'll admit most people I work with wouldn't know w 2nd Law of Thermodynamics from the 1st Law of Motion.
And, yeah, Entropy. It's a killer.
no subject
Dr. Phil
Glad I'm not the only one who was irked by that
(Anonymous) 2010-12-07 10:27 pm (UTC)(link)Wouldn't it be nice to think that schools could graduate every student with enough basic knowledge to understand the stupidity of this commercial?
Re: Glad I'm not the only one who was irked by that
Dr. Phil
Said the exact same thing
I said the exact same thing to my girlfriend after I saw that commercial for the first time. A damn shame...
-Travis
no subject
Dr. Phil
no subject
Toyota clearly doesn't care about truth in advertising. I can't believe the ad is still allowed to air with such blatantly false statements.
Then again, maybe he designed the roller coaster with the loading platform at the top of the highest hill… and everyone has to walk up to it… carrying a bunch of weights which are dropped by the coaster at the bottom..
no subject
Dr. Phil
Благодарность и уважение
(Anonymous) 2011-03-05 09:05 am (UTC)(link)Re: Благодарность и уважение
Google Translate gives it as:
Gratitude and respect
(Anonymous)
2011-03-05 04:05 am (local) (from 213.5.70.215) (link)
Super article. Very well and you have described in detail, thanks.
no subject
Not going to let you hawk your DVD spam crap here on my blog. Go away.
Dr. Phil
no subject
no subject
-- Honestly, where do these people COME from? And why can't they read and see that their brethren spammers got booted ahead of them, so this isn't going to work? Idiots.